The controversy surrounding NAZA, the Israeli documentary that premiered at the Venice International Film Festival on September 10, has widened following scrutiny of director Yuval Abraham’s professional relationship with Gaza-based journalist and activist Ahmed Alnaouq.
Directed by Israeli filmmakers Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, NAZA examines Israel’s military operations in Gaza through interviews with 24 Israeli soldiers and intelligence personnel who spoke anonymously about targeting practices, surveillance and the use of artificial intelligence in military operations. The film received a reported 25-minute standing ovation at its Venice premiere and later won the festival’s Special Jury Prize.
The documentary has drawn strong criticism from Israeli officials and the Israel Defense Forces, which have rejected its allegations and questioned the use of anonymous sources. The IDF has also ordered an investigation into whether classified information was disclosed during the production of the film and has examined the possibility of legal action against those involved.
The latest controversy concerns Abraham’s relationship with Alnaouq, with investigative journalist Eitan Fischberger raising questions about their professional association.
According to reporting by The Jerusalem Post, Abraham contacted Alnaouq in 2019 while researching the views of young people in Gaza. The two subsequently co-founded Across the Wall, an initiative that provided a platform for young Palestinians to publish personal stories that were translated into Hebrew. Abraham has described Alnaouq as a close friend and partner.
Fischberger has also raised questions about Alnaouq’s involvement with the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, commonly known as Euro-Med Monitor. Israeli authorities have designated the organization as a terrorist organization. The characterization of the organization and allegations concerning its personnel remain politically contested, and those claims should not be treated as independently established facts without further verification.
Attention has also focused on the death of Alnaouq’s brother, Ayman, during the 2014 Gaza war. Alnaouq has previously said that his brother was killed in an Israeli airstrike. In accounts cited by The Jerusalem Post, Hamas’s Qassam Brigades later published a memorial image of Ayman showing him with a rifle and wearing a Hamas-associated headband.
In a 2017 interview cited by the Jerusalem Post, Alnaouq discussed his understanding of Palestinian resistance fighters as young people who had left ordinary lives to confront what he described as Israeli occupation and defend Palestinian land. Abraham later described Ayman’s death as a profound personal tragedy.
The scrutiny of Abraham’s relationship with Alnaouq comes as NAZA faces growing political opposition in Israel.
Culture Minister Miki Zohar has called for Abraham and Szor to lose their Israeli citizenship, accusing them of treason and of harming Israel through the film. Far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has also condemned the filmmakers. The legal process for revoking citizenship is subject to specific requirements and does not occur simply on the basis of a ministerial statement.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has described NAZA as “shocking incitement”, while military officials have rejected the documentary’s allegations. IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir has ordered an examination of possible legal action and a separate investigation into the possible disclosure of classified material.
The filmmakers, however, have defended the documentary and its sources. NAZA was produced by The Guardian and JW Films, with Jonathan Glazer serving as an executive producer. The Venice Film Festival lists Abraham and Szor as the film’s directors.
The film’s central allegations concern the way Israeli military and intelligence personnel say targets were selected during the Gaza war. According to the filmmakers, the anonymous sources provided firsthand accounts of military targeting systems and the use of technology, including artificial intelligence, in the selection of targets. The Israeli military has disputed the allegations and questioned whether the anonymous sources can be independently verified.
The dispute over NAZA therefore now involves two separate issues: the documentary’s allegations about Israeli military operations in Gaza and the scrutiny of the professional relationships and backgrounds of people connected to its production.
The film has received international recognition following its Venice premiere, while its contents and the circumstances surrounding its production remain the subject of intense political and public debate in Israel.
For now, the allegations surrounding NAZA, the filmmakers and their associates remain contested. The IDF investigation, the scrutiny of the film’s sources and the political response to the documentary are expected to keep the controversy in the public spotlight as the film moves toward wider international release.

