BBC Faces Fresh Scrutiny Over Gaza Coverage

Published:

The BBC is facing renewed scrutiny over its reporting of journalists killed in Gaza after an investigation identified 53 people on its casualty coverage who had links to terrorist organizations, including individuals later identified as combatants.

The cases have raised questions about how the BBC verified the status of people it described as journalists, particularly on BBC Arabic. The issue has become more significant following a comprehensive review by the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), which has removed 22 people previously listed as journalists or media workers after examining new evidence about their roles and activities.

CPJ said its review was prompted in part by obituaries published by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad identifying some individuals previously recorded as journalists as members or combatants of their armed wings. Under its longstanding methodology, CPJ excludes people from its journalist casualty database when evidence establishes that they were not journalists or media workers, or that they were actively participating in combat.

Among the cases highlighted in the BBC’s coverage is Abdullah Darwish, whom BBC Arabic described as a cameraman for Al-Aqsa TV. CPJ subsequently removed him from its database after research found evidence that he had participated in the October 7, 2023 attacks as a member of Hamas’ Al-Qassam Brigades. Darwish was killed in an Israeli airstrike in December 2023.

Yacoup Al-Barsh, described by BBC Arabic as the executive director of Namaa radio, was also removed by CPJ after he was identified as a member of the Al-Qassam Brigades. Hamas’ military wing subsequently listed him among its “martyrs”. Another case, Rizq Abu Shakian, was described by the BBC as a journalist for Palestine Now. He appeared in an online video wearing Hamas military fatigues and carrying a rifle. CPJ later removed him after its research established that he had participated in combat.

The wider CPJ review has identified numerous other cases in which individuals previously listed as journalists were subsequently removed after evidence of combat participation emerged. Its current database records removals involving people including Abdallah Iyad Breis, Mohamed Nabil Al-Zaq, Mostafa Bakeer, Mohammed Bassam Al Jamal, Tarek El Sayed Abu Skheil and Yahya Abu Manih.

The BBC’s Gaza casualty reporting has also come under scrutiny because many of the disputed descriptions appeared on BBC Arabic. Critics have previously accused the service of failing to maintain sufficient impartiality in its coverage of Israel and Gaza. The Telegraph reported last year that the BBC had promised reforms to BBC Arabic following concerns over its coverage.

Those concerns have persisted. When Matt Brittin began work as the BBC’s director-general in June, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy reportedly told him she continued to have concerns about BBC Arabic.

The latest controversy centres on a list of journalists killed in the conflict that BBC Arabic began publishing and regularly updating after the war began. The list has included more than 180 Palestinians and four Israelis, according to the report.

Critics argue that the inclusion of people subsequently identified as members of armed groups risks blurring the distinction between journalists covering a conflict and combatants who also had connections to media organizations.

Rebecca Paul, the shadow culture secretary, described the latest disclosures as evidence of what she called a “long-running problem with impartiality and accountability” at BBC Arabic.

Danny Cohen, a former director of BBC television, also criticized the broadcaster’s handling of Israel-related coverage, saying the BBC continued to fall short of its obligations on balance and accuracy.

The controversy comes against the backdrop of earlier criticism of BBC Arabic and the wider BBC’s Gaza coverage. The broadcaster was previously accused of giving undue prominence to Hamas claims and of failing to sufficiently distinguish between independently verified information and statements issued by the militant organization.

The BBC also faced criticism over the 2024 documentary Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, which it later acknowledged had been narrated by the son of a Hamas official. Ofcom subsequently found the programme materially misleading and required the BBC to broadcast a statement setting out its findings.

The broadcaster has rejected suggestions that its casualty reporting was intended to favour any side. A BBC spokesman said its report had been updated in August 2025 and covered journalists killed across Gaza, Lebanon and Israel, regardless of their employers’ political affiliations.

The BBC said the information used in its reporting reflected what was available when the material was published. Following CPJ’s subsequent review, the broadcaster said it was examining the cases included in its coverage.

CPJ, meanwhile, has stressed that its own review does not amount to a finding that every journalist affiliated with a militant-linked media organization is a combatant. Its methodology distinguishes between affiliation and direct participation in hostilities. In its September review, the organization said it examined 229 deaths and sought new information, including interviews with people who knew those killed. An external audit found that CPJ had followed its established methodology in the cases it reviewed, while recommending greater clarity in how the organization explains its treatment of alleged combatants.

The dispute therefore extends beyond the question of individual names. It raises a broader issue for international media organizations covering Gaza: how to verify the professional status of local reporters and media workers in a war zone where journalists may work for outlets affiliated with armed groups, evidence can be difficult to independently verify, and militant organizations may later claim individuals as members or “martyrs”.

For the BBC, the renewed scrutiny places particular attention on whether its procedures for identifying and describing journalists are sufficiently rigorous, and whether corrections are made promptly when credible new evidence emerges.

Related articles

Recent articles